I recently heard someone trashing The Hunger Games, saying: "Sorry, I just don't think it's right having children try to kill each other for TV entertainment." The implication was that Suzanne Collins actually endorses those activities, which of course isn't true. She's simply telling a story, not an autobiography, and if anything, her books make a pointed commentary on the extremes our own society goes to for entertainment.
Anyway, it brings up something I see often, this idea that characters' actions or thoughts are what the author believes is THE RIGHT THING. Sure, some authors are preaching a message, and yes, being relatable and likable are important in characters. But that doesn't always mean characters are doing the right things or that they're telling you the right things. Like I said, authors are telling stories, and flawed characters are more interesting than perfect ones.
Which brings me to my main point: Bloodlines. Now, I'm going to talk about stuff in the book, and while it doesn't give away any big plot spoilers, purists who haven't read the book might want to skip this. When Bloodlines came out, I got a few upset emails from people about how *I* was saying that Sydney's size 4 (or 2 in the ARC) figure was too big. But I'm not saying that. Sydney is saying that. She isn't all-knowing or perfect (just really smart), and when she looks in the mirror, she thinks she needs to be a size smaller. Is that true? No, and it's clear from some of the comments others make about her. She looks great, but she doesn't see it that way. She just knows that she doesn't look like those super tall, super slim Moroi. And her dad isn't helping matters!
While I don't like unhealthy body images, I do like that Sydney has this flaw. She's so remarkably observant about the world but blind when it comes to herself. Many of us are, unfortunately, especially with looks. This is an issue that will be revisited in the series, one that she's going to have to work on. This also means you can't always trust Sydney to tell you the truth. That's not to say she's lying to you or that she's not reporting events around her correctly. But, she's telling the story through her eyes, and it's colored by her perceptions. She's our filter. This is true of all books. You can never trust any first person narrator to be telling an objective story, any more than you can in real life. Don't take their opinions as gospel--or as the author's opinion. :)
That's my deep thought for this snowy, icy day in Seattle. I actually meant to write about this months ago, to make sure there weren't readers out there taking the message the wrong way! Bloodlines came out the week my son was born, and like so many other things, this post got delayed. One of these days I'll catch up on all that I want to do...probably when he goes to college...
Anyway, it brings up something I see often, this idea that characters' actions or thoughts are what the author believes is THE RIGHT THING. Sure, some authors are preaching a message, and yes, being relatable and likable are important in characters. But that doesn't always mean characters are doing the right things or that they're telling you the right things. Like I said, authors are telling stories, and flawed characters are more interesting than perfect ones.
Which brings me to my main point: Bloodlines. Now, I'm going to talk about stuff in the book, and while it doesn't give away any big plot spoilers, purists who haven't read the book might want to skip this. When Bloodlines came out, I got a few upset emails from people about how *I* was saying that Sydney's size 4 (or 2 in the ARC) figure was too big. But I'm not saying that. Sydney is saying that. She isn't all-knowing or perfect (just really smart), and when she looks in the mirror, she thinks she needs to be a size smaller. Is that true? No, and it's clear from some of the comments others make about her. She looks great, but she doesn't see it that way. She just knows that she doesn't look like those super tall, super slim Moroi. And her dad isn't helping matters!
While I don't like unhealthy body images, I do like that Sydney has this flaw. She's so remarkably observant about the world but blind when it comes to herself. Many of us are, unfortunately, especially with looks. This is an issue that will be revisited in the series, one that she's going to have to work on. This also means you can't always trust Sydney to tell you the truth. That's not to say she's lying to you or that she's not reporting events around her correctly. But, she's telling the story through her eyes, and it's colored by her perceptions. She's our filter. This is true of all books. You can never trust any first person narrator to be telling an objective story, any more than you can in real life. Don't take their opinions as gospel--or as the author's opinion. :)
That's my deep thought for this snowy, icy day in Seattle. I actually meant to write about this months ago, to make sure there weren't readers out there taking the message the wrong way! Bloodlines came out the week my son was born, and like so many other things, this post got delayed. One of these days I'll catch up on all that I want to do...probably when he goes to college...
- Current Location:Lair
- Current Mood:
contemplative


Comments
I read your adult and YA novels, and share the YA novels with my 16 year old. (I've tried to get her hooked on the Georgina novels, but she's not biting - thinks she has to find the cool stuff on her own. hmph!) We chatted about Sydney's body image issues and wondered where the story was going with it. Certainly it seemed important and we were hoping it might be developed further in later novels.
Have fun, folks! Challenge yourselves to question what you're being told -- and don't follow it so easily! Do you really believe that Bella Swan being a mindless manipulated tool of an overpowering boyfriend who prevents friendships, kidnaps her, and disconnects her car when she does things he doesn't like is the *perfect* boyfriend? Yikes. A real man isn't afraid of a woman who makes her own choices.
I love Sydney, which was a huge shock, b/c I thought I would get irritated with her so quickly. She is a fun, quirky character. I should have known better after reading all of your other books! I am really looking forward to the next book!
It is nice to have someone who relates to that.
Thank you for giving me something to look forward to. New Bloodlines coming out.
Thank you so much for addressing this writerly issue! I was having very similar thoughts when I was reading about your readers who were upset about the end of Shadow Heir because they didn't like the choices Eugenie made because they felt they weren't the "right" decisions. However, Eugenie, like all your interesting characters, is flawed, and I think the decisions she made at the end were consistent with her flawed character. It would have been a less satisfactory ending if she suddenly because perfect because that would have been unrealistic. Readers need to take a moment and think about how boring it would be if authors only created perfect characters who always did the right thing and had high self-esteem and who everyone loved. I'm falling asleep just thinking about it!
-DiDi
Also this has nothing to do with the post but I really can't wait to read Shadow Heir. Being as it has yet to come out in England. I'm intreeged to find out the 'twist' at the end. And although you plainly stated it would be better not to read your post about it I still did. But I just can't wait.
Annie
the story will not as fun as it should be, if everyone is perfect, beside in real life nobody's perfect.
Thank you for this post as everything you wrote is true.
Sydney FTW!
I have a cat myself. She is lovely and cute and amazing. I love her to bits. I have never had the desire to throw her from a skyscraper to see if she still lands on her feet at the bottom.....
Many people accept the views of characters in books as the truth. My book is a comedy so it should be clear, but some people don't think about the fact that their view of our fabricated world is filtered through the opinions of the main character.
Anyway, the idea fascinates me and I love books and films that emphasise this: 'Memento', 'Rashomon' etc.
Edited at 2012-01-20 11:51 am (UTC)
i automatically saw sydney's body image issues as just that - issues. like, it was obvious that this was something she had to deal with, that it was a flaw. i think you do a pretty good job of keeping the characters well rounded with both strengths and short comings (adrian comes to mind, as does rose - and she was often aware of when she was being unreasonable...)
anyway, this is my ramble way of saying i agree. ;)
Now, on a different note, when are you gonna post some Golden Lily teasers again? You know I've been obsessing over Sydrian ever since I read Bloodlines, which was on August 24th last week.
Edited at 2012-01-21 07:56 am (UTC)
Oh! Congrats on your little boy! ♥
And being that body image is such a big deal right now, I think it's a good story to write out. I look forward to seeing how she deals with it in the upcoming books.
As for your book, I think the majority of us (aka: your fans) realize that it's just a story and it's Sydney talking - not you. Hopefully people aren't being too critical!
I think what people need to pay more attention to are the messages that the story gives, and stop narrowing in on specific things the characters say or do. Without a character arc, the story would be insanely boring.
Okay, I think I've left you a long enough comment. Keep writing! I LOVE your work. :)